In some cases, a surgeon may perform a meniscus transplant, putting a donor meniscus from a cadaver into the knee joint of a patient with a severely damaged meniscus. However, this procedure is rare, because it requires very specific conditions to be successful. First, the patient must meet strict eligibility requirements:
- Under 45 years old
- Physically active
- Already missing a large portion of the meniscus from a previous surgery OR with a severely damaged meniscus that needs to be removed
- Persistent pain in the knee
- Little to no osteoarthritis of the knee
- Healthy weight
- Knee is otherwise healthy
It's rare for a patient to meet all these requirements. Usually, if a person is missing a significant portion of the meniscus and has severe enough knee pain to justify another operation, they already have too much osteoarthritis to be eligible for a transplant. The procedure is sometimes performed in young people with serious knee injuries to prevent osteoarthritis from developing early.
In addition to the patient meeting these strict requirements, the surgeon also needs to locate a donor meniscus of the appropriate size to be a good fit for the patient, which further narrows the possibility of a transplant. The operation has a fairly high failure rate, but can be hugely beneficial to the right candidate when it's successful.
Recently, medical science has pursued synthetic meniscal implants that may be a good alternative to meniscectomy or meniscus transplant. However, these products are relatively new, and studies are still underway to determine whether they are a viable long-term solution.