Without proper care, a tear in your ACL (anterior cruciate ligament) can be a debilitating injury, especially for athletes and people who live an active lifestyle. When the tear is severe, you may need ACL reconstruction surgery to restore function and stability to the knee.
What is ACL reconstruction surgery?
ACL reconstruction is used to treat complete tears of the anterior cruciate ligament, one of several pieces of connective tissue that stabilize your knee. If you tear the ACL completely, it can't repair itself. When that happens, a surgeon can take connective tissue from elsewhere in your body and graft it to your knee to perform the function of your torn ACL. In some cases, you may choose to receive a graft from a tissue donor rather than from your own body.
ACL repair vs reconstruction
Not every torn ACL requires reconstruction. An ACL repair sews the existing ACL tissue back together, whereas an ACL reconstructive surgery uses a tissue graft to replace the torn ACL.
When a repair is possible, some doctors believe it leads to a faster recovery. However, older techniques for ACL repair have high failure rates, and modern repair techniques don’t yet have much data on long-term outcomes. For now, ACL reconstruction is still the standard of care in most cases.
Who is a candidate for ACL reconstruction surgery?
ACL reconstruction can be an appropriate treatment for active patients who have a completely torn ACL, especially younger patients who play sports that place high demands on the knee. Older patients whose lives don't include sports that require rapid pivoting, like basketball, soccer, and tennis, may be able to get by without surgery, even living relatively comfortably with a completely torn ACL.
ACL reconstruction surgery is especially important for young athletes who perform sports involving rapid direction changes, such as cutting and pivoting movements. Without an intact ACL, these athletes are at higher risk of other knee injuries, including a torn meniscus.
However, people with partial tears, especially young patients, don't always need surgery. A partial tear to an ACL may heal on its own.
A Mass General Brigham sports medicine specialist can assess the degree of your ACL tear using physical tests, such as the Lachmann test and the pivot shift test, which evaluate your knee's stability. Based on the results of the tests and other factors like age, medical history, and lifestyle, your care team will determine whether to treat your ACL injury surgically.
Other considerations about eligibility
Patients who are candidates for ACL reconstructive surgery need to wait about a month after the injury before having the procedure. This gives time for the swelling to go down and the knee to regain mobility. Undergoing surgery too early can cause scarring in the knee that may limit range of motion after the operation.
On the other hand, you shouldn't wait too long to see a doctor, who will help you determine a surgical or nonsurgical treatment plan. Waiting too long can cause other (potentially permanent) injuries due to instability in the knee and may increase your risk of needing a second surgery, called a revision, to repair the graft.
How does ACL reconstruction surgery work?
Modern ACL reconstruction surgery is a minimally invasive procedure using arthroscopic techniques. Your surgeon will make a few small incisions around your knee area and a larger one where they harvest the tissue graft. The surgeon will insert small instruments and a camera into these openings to perform the surgery with minimal trauma to your body.
During the surgery, the surgeon will cut away the remains of your damaged ACL. Then, they'll collect a piece of connective tissue from elsewhere in your body, most commonly the hamstring, patellar (kneecap) tendon, or the quadriceps tendon. They'll drill two small tunnels where the ACL should attach, insert the ends of the graft tissue into the holes, and secure the tendon to the bone using screws, buttons, or other hardware. The ACL reconstruction fixture hardware is typically permanent without a need for future removal.
ACL reconstruction surgery cost
For many people, cost is a serious concern when getting medical care, especially surgery. The average cost of ACL reconstructive surgery in the U.S. is around $10,000, though prices vary considerably. Fortunately, many insurance plans—including Medicare and Medicaid—cover ACL surgery when it's medically necessary.
Preparing for ACL reconstruction surgery
The knee is a delicate joint, and ACL reconstruction is a major surgery that places a lot of demands on your body in recovery. You'll need to follow some guidelines in the period before you have ACL reconstructive surgery to achieve the best results.
As you get ready for surgery, you should:
- Practice using crutches: ACL surgery is typically an outpatient procedure, which means you'll go home the same day you have the operation. However, you won't be able to walk normally for a while after the operation, so you should get used to crutches ahead of time.
- Ask your doctor about medicines: Talk with your healthcare provider about any medications you take. You may need to temporarily stop medications that can affect the surgery and recovery period, such as blood thinners.
- Find out what anesthesia you'll receive: ACL surgery is usually performed under general anesthesia, but some facilities use other methods. The type of anesthesia and the timing of your operation will affect when you need to stop eating before your surgery.
- Bring comfortable clothes: Your knee will be stiff and swollen after the procedure, so it's helpful to bring comfortable, loose-fitting clothes.
- Get your knee in shape: ACL surgery can have severe complications if your knee is still inflamed when you have the operation. Treating it with ice, anti-inflammatory drugs, and physical therapy exercises can help you reduce inflammation before the operation.
Pre-ACL reconstruction exercises
Along with rest, ice, and anti-inflammatories, performing "pre-hab" physical therapy exercises can help you achieve the best possible outcomes from your surgery. You'll be prescribed a physical therapy regimen to prepare your knee for the operation, which can lead to better results. The program will focus on restoring function to the muscles that support the knee, regaining range of motion, and reducing swelling in the knee.
What happens during ACL reconstruction surgery?
On the day of your operation, you'll come to the hospital with a friend or family member who can take you home afterward. Bring a comfortable change of clothes, crutches, a leg brace, and proof of insurance. You'll need to come to the hospital on an empty stomach—your care team will give you specific directions on when to stop eating and drinking.
You'll receive anesthesia, and the surgeon will perform the operation. Afterward, you'll wake up and be kept for observation for a short time.
How long does ACL reconstruction take?
ACL reconstruction surgery typically takes about two and a half hours.
What to expect after ACL reconstruction surgery
Most people are sent home the same day as their procedure. If you have problems with anesthesia, you may stay overnight for observation. When it's time to go, you'll be able to walk with crutches and a leg brace, but you'll need someone to accompany you.
You may experience pain in the first few days after your surgery, though your doctor will also prescribe pain medication. Some people experience discomfort due to the screws that hold the reconstructed ACL in place.
Scarring after your ACL reconstructive surgery should be minimal, with just thin scars developing at the incision sites. In rare cases, you may experience a thicker scar. Too much internal scarring can cause functional problems, but effective pre-hab can reduce the amount of scarring inside the knee and support good knee function after the operation.
Recovery from ACL reconstruction
Returning to your activities, especially sports, can take up to a year after ACL reconstructive surgery, depending on your age, health, medical history, lifestyle, and other factors.